The national elections are over, and political minds in El Paso are turning to the spring city council elections.
Mayor John Cook has already said he’s running for a second, four-year term, and Northeast city Rep. Melina Castro is open about her plans to seek re-election.
On Tuesday, Northeast resident Walt Phillips, who is active in a variety of civic causes, made his intentions to run for the Northeast seat known by filing his designation of a campaign treasurer, which he must have to spend or receive more than $500 on a campaign.
Also planning to run is Northeast activist Carl Robinson.
Phillips, 71, is a special education teacher and said he and his students run the El Paso school district’s paper shredding and recycling program. He plans to retire at the end of the year and to mount his first election campaign.
“I think people will listen to someone who will work for their interests and who can’t be bought,” Phillips said.
Phillips, who has been critical of Castro in the past, acknowledged that she has gotten better in her last year in office.
“She’s learning, but why did it task her four years to learn?” he said.
Phillips said he understands that if Castro were re-elected, she would be unable to take office because she owes the city more than $40,000 stemming from a lawsuit she filed against City Attorney Charles McNabb.
The City Charter prohibits anyone who owes money to the city from being sworn into elective office.
But Mayor John Cook said the city attorney’s office disagrees with Phillips’ view because as long as Castro’s suit is on appeal, there is no final judgment and, so, no debt.
In her suit three years ago, Castro accused McNabb of withholding documents from her regarding a settlement City Council approved with a previous city attorney, Rita Rodriguez.
Castro lost her case at the district court level, and the judge capped the court costs the city was entitled to at $30,000. The judge on the case also advised Castro that she would have to pay the city an additional $10,000 if she appealed and lost.
A losing appeal to the Texas Supreme Court would result in an additional court cost assessment of $17,000, the judge advised Castro.
Castro’s appeal is pending before the state’s Eighth Court of Appeals in El Paso and was scheduled to be heard Oct. 23, but Castro requested and got a postponement.
“Now, it is possible that the judgment would not be final before the May election,” Cook said, and that would mean she could take office if elected.
So far, the mayor said, Castro’s case has actually cost the city more than $60,000 in outside legal fees, but the attorney involved has capped his bill for the city at $60,000. However, further appeals could run that bill up.
Today’s telephone interview with Castro was disconnected before Newspaper Tree could ask Castro about her lawsuit.
But before the interview ended, Castro confirmed her intention to run again next spring.
“Definitely. If my constituents want me back, I’ll try it again,” she said.
Asked to cite several of her accomplishments in the past 3-1/2 years, Castro said she has consistently voted to hold down taxes and fees.
She acknowledged that she was usually on the losing end of those votes, but said her efforts were not without results.
“I didn’t win, but if I didn’t fight the battles I did, it would probably be worse,” she said. “If we were to say yes to everything, I don’t think that would be good policy-making.
“We have the right to ask questions and challenge the ideas to make sure we are making responsible decisions on how we spend people’s tax dollars.”
Robinson, who is 62 and retired, calls himself a community activist, as opposed to Phillips, who says he is active in the community.
Robinson ran for the open Northeast seat in the race that Castro won in 2005, said he wants to run to make a difference.
“The way I see it is our district is not being well represented,” he said. “The voice of the people needs to be heard and recognized.”
Asked what he meant by that, Robinson said, “As a representative, I have to realize that while my district is District 4, the decisions I make impact the city as a whole.
“I can’t just focus on my district. I have to be able to work with all the representatives to accomplish those things that we may want and need in this district.”


















Trooper
November 5, 2008
Robinson has run for city rep. about 10 times and lost. Get the hint Carl. What else have you run for and lost? Oh, that's right you have ran for everything there is.
Carl says:
"I can’t just focus on my district."
Then who's district are you going to focus on Carl? The Westside? You have not even gotten started and already you lost my vote.
Lisle H. Davis
November 6, 2008
In light of the local FBI investigations and, If we've learned anything from the embarrasment of the unvetted Sarah Palin being selected by the GOP as their VP, I would strongly urge that each candidate for District #4' upcoming election be seriously and carefully vetted.
Lisle
Advocate
November 6, 2008
The one and only time I had the displeasure of actually meeting Robinson was after a city council meeting. I was speaking with a woman who had spoken during public comments and Robinson walked up to us and weazled his way into our discussion, literally. He maneuvered himself between the two of us and started talking to this young lady (I think they had met before)- and after about a minute he introduced himself to me and handed me a card with his name on it saying he was planning to run for city council. He didn't explain his stand on any issues- so I guess he wanted me to judge him on his acts. Ok- I'll oblige- you were rude, Mr, Robinson, and you didn't even apologize- so you're arrogant, too. That's ALL I have to go on- but now I see that when he does open his mouth he puts his foot into it- according to the quotes in this article. Won't be voting for him!
As for Walt Phillips- he's too wishy-washy. He may make comments here and there that on the surface look like he is an independant thinker- but he's too close to Mr. Cook and I'm sure he'll side with him on most issues. Soon El Paso will look like ANYTOWN, USA and our taxes will be even higher.
Castro is the only viable contender at the moment. El Paso needs someone to question the attitude of "spend like crazy cause we don't want to be known as a dusty border town and we should be grateful someone wants to invest in us". We DO have choices people.
Emilia R. Taylor
November 7, 2008
If Ms Castro is so interested in holding down taxes and fees why doesn't se pay up what she owes the city.
I understand that taxes and fees are needed to keep our city operating and am willing to pay my share but I want everybody else to also pay their fair share.
I know Mr. Walt Phillips and he would make a very good council member as would Mr. Carl Robinson. They would bring integrity to the council.
Saul
November 7, 2008
I don't live in the NE, cant vote there. But I pray that City Council can rid itself of both Castro and Quintana. They are both ignorant -- maybe not stupid but definitely ignorant. Anyone who has had the misfortune of having to sit through a City Council meeting knows that neither one is up to the job. Surely there is someone more qualified!
CNEC
November 7, 2008
Castro has been ineffective, rude, and arrogant (though I do agree with Walt Phillips - she has improved somewhat). Too little too late. Castro claims to listen to her constituents but last I knew, Luther Jones is does not live in District 4.
I agree, Advocate. I met Carl Robinson last time he ran and he could not answer me when I asked why he thought he should be the NE Rep.
Whenever Walt Phillips has addressed Council, he has done so with integrity. He never yells but he does get his point across. I also have noticed he is very involved in different youth activities. Seems like the best one.
vatoman
November 8, 2008
Melina Castro won her seat in Northeast while living out on the far east side. Now she lives with her hubby in Cd. Juarez. Moreover, she represents Luther Jones and Bob Bowling, not the people of the district her mother lives in. Melina Castro will fade away like other forgettable City representatives. Her time on City Council was a waste of time for her constituents as she represented the political Troika who put Joe Wardy in office and is ready to name their candidate for Mayor. Melina did her job representing these vested business interests who want to return to power and control El Paso in the tradition of Jonathan Rogers, Fred Hervey and Larry Francis.
Goodbye to the pretty little lady with no brains and no sense of ethics.
B. Rodriguez
November 12, 2008
JEROME TILGHMAN!