The massacre took place at 7:15 p.m. Wednesday, Aug. 13, 2008 at the CIAD (Center for Drug and Alcohol Integration) Rehabilitation Center #8 in the Colonia First of September. It was the single most deadly violent incident in Juárez in recent times.
Socorro Garcia, a pastor from the Blessed Works Christian Family Center, an Assembly of God congregation, had come to preach the gospel to some 30 or so residents receiving counseling and treatment for their addictions. She stood at the podium in the little conference room and gave the invitation to those at the prayer meeting to come forward and give their lives to Jesus. Many had their arms raised, faces turned toward heaven, praising the Lord and asking to be saved. At that moment at least four masked and hooded gunmen burst into the room and began to shoot. According to Socorro, “…the bullets came from all directions, from the right and the left, meanwhile I was crying out to God to send His angels to protect us and I saw the young people falling injured all around me and others managed to run for their lives…”
When the shooting stopped, bodies lay all over the room. The director of the center (who has not been identified in press accounts) lay with his body over another pastor’s wife. She and her unborn child survived. The man died. Joel Valles, 47, a deacon of the church, was also killed in the attack. Other witnesses reported that before commencing to shoot everyone in the room, the assassins dragged several people out to the patio, threw them face down and shot them at point blank range.
The gunfire went on for 15 minutes.
Media reports say that at least eight (some say nine) people died at the scene. Five others were taken to the hospital with serious gunshot wounds, transported in the old van belonging to the rehab center because too much time went by before a Mexican Red Cross ambulance arrived. One young man, Luis Angel Gonzalez, was found lying dead at the nearby intersection of Zaragoza Boulevard and Avenida de los Aztecas. He lived in the house next door to the center and had begun to seek detox help there a week and a half earlier for his addiction to glue and solvents.
Juárez papers the next morning reported eyewitness testimony that a group of seven or eight men wearing the uniforms of a special Mexican Army unit—the Red Berets—and traveling in an official-looking white Ford Lobo pickup, had parked at the corner of Barranco Azul and Casa de Janos streets, about 50 yards away from the site of the massacre. A pair of state police agents on their way to the crime scene also reported seeing the soldiers. These and other witnesses expressed anger and mistrust toward the authorities because they saw the soldiers nearby, but no one came to the aid of those being attacked, even though the gunfire could be heard for blocks. Residents close to the center hid in their houses when the shooting broke out, but a few managed to call the Emergency Response Center. Yet, witnesses said that the soldiers parked nearby did not come and that the truck drove past the front gate of the center at high speed while the bullets were still flying. No one stopped. No one came. The gunfire lasted for 15 minutes.
“We are sure that the soldiers were guarding the killers or maybe they came with them so that the police would not be able to intervene. They had to have known what was going on because they passed right in front of the center.” The witness, quoted in the newspaper, asked not to be identified for fear of reprisals. The newspaper also said that an unnamed source inside the Mexican Army denied that the military had carried out any operation at the scene or that they were aware of what had happened. Later, municipal police cordoned off the area and offered no help to the wounded. By the afternoon, the eyewitness accounts of the army soldiers had disappeared from the English language wire reports.
Did I mention that the high caliber gunfire went on for 15 minutes?
***
I sit at my computer early Thursday morning and almost forget to check the Juárez papers as I’ve done compulsively nearly every day this year, trying to keep track of the unprecedented violence in the city. At the time I write in mid-August, the toll has climbed to more than 815, more than 120 in the first 15 days of August alone. I’m jaded, addicted to the numbers, the tally, how many killed today? This week, this month, this year? The headline, “Asesina commando a 9,” wiped the callousness away. I grew up going to a tiny Baptist church. The idea of people mown down by gunfire during the “invitation” at a prayer meeting—this is evil. I contact a reporter working on the Juárez story.
The next morning we drive up to the high ground on the southwest side of the city, crowned on the side of a hill by the Cementos de Chihuahua plant. Some of the residents of CIAD #8 tried to escape the massacre by jumping over the fence in back of their building and ran toward the cement plant to hide. The truck feels tired even before we turn off the paved avenue onto the broken cement and gravel of Casa de Janos street. The CIAD building is painted white, in fact, we can barely see the shadow of the logo under its brand new whitewash. We are there less than 40 hours after the massacre and the place has already been shut down.
Next door is a house where some 40 people are gathered on chairs under a dirty canvas shelter. It is the wake for Luis Angel, the teenager left for dead on a nearby corner. His grandmother, Librada Limones, 79, saw his body on the street. “His head was very bad, his body was covered with blood. I got close to him but he no longer had any reaction. He stayed there a long time, they were going to take him to a clinic but they never made it and they left him there." She was hospitalized with heart trouble the next morning.
The coffin is in the kitchen of the cement block house and perhaps a dozen people are sitting and standing in the room. Over the sink is a row of old cups holding toothbrushes. His mother is small with long dark hair, her eyes are red. She looks tired and sad and agrees to answer our questions with a resigned shrug. She sits in a small row of chairs with several other middle-aged women in front of a banner painted in gang graffiti style, “REST IN PEACE.” A constant stream of young people, mostly girls, but a few boys with piercings and tattoos come into the dark room to look inside the glass window of the coffin at the boy’s face. His eyelashes are long and lie slightly curled on his smooth face, a pencil-thin mustache traces his upper lip. He is dressed in a peach and white polo shirt and above the glass are photographs of Luis Angel with his friends. In one photo, the boys flash gang signs with their hands. The mother tells us that when they heard the shooting next door, they hid for a long time. My friend asks permission to take photographs. Luis Angel’s mother goes away, we talk to some of the other women. One lost her son a few weeks earlier. She says a police patrol came and took him away one night while she was working. He was 25. Several days later, his body was found assassinated in the street.
When we go back out to the street, the metal gate in front of the CIAD #8 is open. Several vans with Sonora plates are parked haphazardly on the sidewalk. We walk through the gate into the patio. Several guys are up on the roof tossing bundles of plaid blankets from the dormitory upstairs down to the ground. The same blankets that often appear in murder stories in the newspaper, wrapping victims tossed into the streets. These bodies are known as “encobijados.” In the rooms are discarded sandals and odd shoes. Pill boxes tossed on the floor of the tiny clinic. Upstairs in the bedrooms are a few books and religious tracts, odd bits of clothing, towels, an empty cedar box that might have held something very personal, a velvet painting of an Aztec eagle.
Workers dismantle metal bedframes and haul the pieces out to the vans. Eventually, they toss the blankets into garbage barrels on the street. The CIAD organization is based in Cananea, Sonora and operates a chain of rehab centers in the border region, including three centers in Juárez. On Aug. 1, two men were shot and killed at another center and there were other warnings. One center had been closed and abandoned since last Sunday. Between 80-100 inmates scattered and workers erased their logos from the buildings and left clear messages on the walls: “This Center is leaving Cd. Juárez,” “This place is Closed” “We are leaving this city.” Inmates had traditionally raised money for their rehabilitation by selling candies and seeking donations at busy intersections all over the city. As of last week, other street vendors said that the reformed addicts had abandoned their posts. The men cleaning up on Friday at CIAD #8 were driving from Sonora on Wednesday to help in shutting down the remaining Juárez centers. They arrived two hours after the massacre. They also said that they had told the authorities that they were closing down and leaving town. They had asked the police and the army for protection. They arrived too late for CIAD #8.
None of the guys working on Friday give their names, but they have no trouble with a couple of Americans being there while they work. In fact, they probably figured that as long as we were there, it was less likely the hooded men with AKs would return. The guy in charge from Cananea took us into the Conference Room where at least four or five people had died. It was about 30 feet long and perhaps 12 feet wide, painted white and dark yellow, an uneven floor of mismatched ceramic tiles of various colors. A dozen or more people attending the prayer service had tried to save themselves by running into the tiny bathroom at the back corner.
In the opposite corner, blood splatters and fingerprints smeared the floor and wall, dark brown stains soaked the seams between the tiles, chipped and cracked where the bullets hit. The man said the bodies had piled up here and the blood pooled in this corner. Now a small crucifix leaned against the wall, a red Virgen of Guadalupe candle burned down and someone had placed a burning cigarette on end in front of the candle. Mounted on the wall were the 12-steps of Alcoholics Anonymous and a piece of paper was taped over a tiny window with the words of the Serenity Prayer in Spanish. A man from Imuris, Sonora talked to me quietly in that corner. He showed me the thick callous on his arms where he had injected himself, but he had been clean now for more than three years and believed in rehabilitation. He wondered why the centers had been targeted. “All we do is detox, counseling, we try to get people jobs.”
The man took us out to the patio where the killers had dragged four people out of the meeting and shot them with AK-47s as they lay face down on the ground. Bullet holes marked the cream-colored walls. A passage about two feet wide ran between the external and internal walls on the street side of the building. Here, the office secretary tried to run to safety but he was chased down the passage by AK rifle fire. He managed to climb a metal ladder to the roof where the killers mowed him down. I can easily put two fingers through the bullet holes shot into the thick metal window frame along the narrow passage.
***
After a couple of hours, it is time to leave. The men have salvaged the little there was of value in the building and we know they are terrified and desire nothing more than to get out of Juárez as quickly as they can. We ask the man who does not give his name but who has given us his time: What is going on in Juárez? “Something evil. Something very very evil.”
And I go away thinking of recent mass murders in my country and of all the cop and crime scene shows so popular on TV. And I realize that less than 48 hours after this horrific crime, no evidence remains at all. No investigation will ever take place. Not one shred of crime scene tape can be seen. The blood is mostly washed away. The bodies are buried. The family next door saw the killers drive away up the street toward the main avenue that leads to the cement plant. The soldiers sped away to their barracks about a mile to the south. The newspapers print verbatim the communiqués from the state investigators: 61 ballistic elements of various calibers secured at the scene, 9 mm, 7.62 x 39, .223 and 40 mm. The names of the dead and injured appear in neat lists. The numbers never quite match up. And there will be no arrests.
When I tell this story to friends, they ask why? Some say it is like El Salvador in the 1980s, except that there is no Cold War, no ideology that can explain it. U.S. press accounts say it is a drug cartel war, but nothing about the sad faces of the CIAD workers or the defeated families of the dead in this poor barrio can be connected to these cartels generating billions with their commerce. The newspapers, the politicians, the academics never say what the victims know: something evil, something very very evil.
On Saturday afternoon, less than 72 hours after the biggest single-incident mass murder in recent Juárez history, 14 people, including an 18-month old baby, are gunned down at a party in the Sierra Tarahumara tourist town of Creel, Chihuahua. Most of the dead are members of a prominent family in the region. State justice officials appear on the scene to lead the investigation and launch a massive search for the killers by land and air.
And in Colonia First of September in Juárez, families hold funerals for the drug addicts, workers and church people killed at CIAD #8. The rehab workers head back to their headquarters in Sonora where they hope they will be safe. Blankets are dumped, perhaps to be burned but more likely to be reclaimed, washed and used again. White paint washes the walls and across the street, in front of Luis Angel’s house, his gang has left a message: Locos 23. RIP.


















dave
August 18, 2008
thanks for writing this.
Erin
August 19, 2008
Yes, thanks for writing this....for not allowing it to disappear. More need to know what is going on.
jb
August 19, 2008
As we all know by now, the situation is hopeless....whatever is going on in Cd Jz is beyond my scope of reasoning or understanding, and the horror creeps into my soul, blood, and bones.
by the sword
August 19, 2008
What's going on in Juarez? Nothing anymore evil than what has gone on in Central and S. America for the last 20 years. Only now its closer to home, so now people are paying attention.
Everybody's in on the violence, narcos, police, soldiers, even evangelicals, so everyone is a target, e.g. -- the recent story of the guy caught smuggling automatic weapons to Juarez in van used by an orphanage there. They were evangelicals, supposedly trying to get more firepower to the outgunned police.
Bill Guerra-Addington
August 19, 2008
I have close ties to Cd. Juarez. My great uncle, Domingo Tamez started the first electric company there. I love the good people in Juarez. How can other 'humans' be so cruel? These murderers have very sick, troubled and sad souls. God will have the final judgment for them.
Evil. Pure evil. God help us. I pray for our brothers and sisters in Juarez.
And I cry tears of Blood.
Bill Guerra-Addington
Sierra Blanca and El Paso
helen marshall
August 19, 2008
What can it mean, "something evil, something very very evil..." If it is not the drug cartels, who? What is the future for this city, this country? And what does it mean for El Paso? And for the US????
Are these centers targeted because their work will remove customers for the drug traffickers?
When will we reconsider our own failed drug policies?
Too many questions. No answers.
Carlos
August 19, 2008
The witness that thinks that the soldiers did not stop because she thinks maybe they where protecting the shooters is correct that's exactly what is going on. The Mexican Govt. wants to put El Chapo Guzman in command of the drug dealing in the border so the government are helping him clean the "mess" (too many drug dealers that are not paying a fee for working) so he can stay in control. And that is the main purpose of sending the military...not to protect the citizens but the shooters.
angel
August 19, 2008
Thank you for your articles. This is so evil, and by the looks of it, won't end anytime soon. God bless those poor people who can't even rely on their own authorities to protect them - may God protect them!
carlos
August 19, 2008
The news in Mexico city said (about the 14 killed in Creel) that it is very interesting that the military left ( I think were near the place about to be hit, I guess informing the shooters where their target was) just 10-15 minutes before the shooting started and came back 15-20 minutes later after the shooting as if they where instructed to leave. mmm? Now that is interesting! This guys (military) are payed large amounts of money to be look outs and too keep out of the way.
kathy
August 19, 2008
while you hate reading about such terrible violence, this story has a great place in what is happening in the Juarez/El Paso area right now. People need to know it. They say it will not come over the river-I doubt they are right. These thugs are literally getting away with murder-no rhyme or reason to it. It is not going to stop and the bigger their egos get, the more brazen they become. It will invade El Paso. Sooner rather than later.
Juan Arturo Muro
August 19, 2008
Sad. Real. Aggravating.
news
August 19, 2008
Today I saw National Geographic's story on the border wars. It didn't go too much into the drug violence.
Newsmax had two stories relating to El Paso. One about the hospital treatment of the vicitms of Mexican drug violence the other in LA TImes related to the massacre and the 800+ mass graves in Juarez...
Unfortunately that deadliness doesn't discriminate. It is a crisis it is escalating.
Chief Allen rightly called it terrorism.
sl
August 20, 2008
What are we doing sending 1.6 billion dollars to a government that will not address the issue..?
VB
August 20, 2008
thanks for being such an excellent news source, esp. on the Jaurez murders.
Hugh
August 23, 2008
Why?
Tony Lewis
August 23, 2008
Good job under such difficult and risky situations,keep trying to send these to Washington. The late sherriff L.S. said it was going to get worse ( more detiails ). Eventually we will need to use our troops on the border.....
Andy Krafsur
August 23, 2008
This is the most compelling story I've read on the violence in Juarez. This story needs to be told by NY Times, Wall Street Journal, Chicago Tribune, and the major news outlets and hoepfully become part of our national dialogue. This is a humanitarian crisis in an election year.
Even those who believe that so long as this violence is confined to Mexico, it's not our problem, need to face facts. This is headed OUR way. It's like the weather, it's not going to stay stormy in Juarez and sunny in El Paso forever.
Once fear gets a hold of a community, it doesn't let go.
Bill
August 23, 2008
Excellent story. This is something that should appear nationwide.
Scott
August 23, 2008
It seems logical that the Mexican government is assisting in the transfer of power. (Good insights Carlos)This seems like the speedy solution to a very complex mess; especially, since the violence parallels our own gangland style killings, which took place in the USA during prohibition of alcohol during the Roaring Twenties and the Depression. What would be the only other logical alternative? Well, legalize narcotics. Yea right. imagine the real work that the governments of both the US and Mexico would have to do in order to make that happen. The sad thing about this is that the corruption is so obvious: why didn't they do an investigation? And, who the hell were these idiots in the red berets and what were they actually doing so close to the crime scene?
Ken G
August 23, 2008
The violence in Cd. Juarez is totally out of control and horrible. Why hasn't it crossed the river? I think there are two main reasons and probably many minor ones. The big two, US police, sheriff's deputies, BP, FBI, DEA agents, etc are less corruptable than those in Mexico. Not uncorruptible as we have see but far less corruptible than underpaid Mexican officials. The second major is different weapons' laws. Law abiding Mexican citizens can't have home defence weapons. Armed thugs know this and rule by the gun.
I am the Walrus
August 24, 2008
These tragic deaths are a purging of one cartel to make room for another. Drugs is a business, and instability is not good for business, even the drug business. This violent purging is ultimately trying to stabilize power and control, so they can resume the smooth clandestine drug operation, funneling illegal drugs into the streets of Juarez, and into the hands of US drug users who are at the source of the problem.
Many readers ask "Why?" Many say "evil, pure evil." I cannot disagree with that, but what i can say is that there is a logic to it. The vast majority of violent deaths in Juarez are arranged, organized, and initiated to bring order and control back into the industry. It sounds callous, I realize that, but it is the truth.
Those whose hearts are hurt by death, are indeed crying tears of blood, as Mr. Addington poignantly said. So many of us have our roots in that town, so many stories of visiting when we were young, of hearing how our fathers shined shoes there, how our parents, when they were young, went to "Watafil" (Waterfill, or Zaragosa) to have fun, to dance, to get haircuts and the men receive the traditional barber shave. That is the spirit of Juarez, our beloved sister city.
As hard as it is, let's try and remember that in all things there are logic, a system driving it. Death is related to three things: A hatred of oneself, which is manifested by suicide or predatorial killings; Personal revenge killings dealing with love or pride; and death that relates to keeping money and power.
What we are seeing in Juarez is death motivated by the human impulse to keep money and power. But let's not lose hope, and, please forgive me if I appear callous or too analytical for such a horrific plague engulfing our neighbors, but this violence will pass, once stability is achieved. But the end to this episode can be hastened by us, the good people of El Paso.
I have many friends in Juarez, spend much time writing in Juarez, so often times lost on the myriad of streets. And whenever i needed help, all I had to do was roll down my window, and call out "Amigo, me puedes ayudar?" ("Friend, can you help me?") and out from the crowd a friend would alway appear, willing to stop what he or she was doing to offer help, to provide directions, to hop in the car and assist me, a total stranger find my destination or answer my question with a smile and handshake of genuine friendship. That is the spirit of Juarez.
How can the violence be stopped? Recall this passage from Malloy: "None of the guys working on Friday give their names, but they have no trouble with a couple of Americans being there while they work. In fact, they probably figured that as long as we were there, it was less likely the hooded men with AKs would return."
That, friends, in my humble opinion is the only way to stop the violence, or have the drug organization reorganize in a less violent way: the presence of visitors, of Americans, of Germans, of Japanese, of people from around the world stepping into the friendly arms of Juarez, forcing the cartel element to double, triple, quadruple think about pulling a trigger that may injure or kill visiting tourists.
Cartels have orders to avoid killing those not involved with the drug war. There is a list of those to be killed. It is targeted and coordinated. But it is the messy crossfire that concerns us, and concerns the cartels as well. More visitors into Juarez, more effort to demonstrate that Juarez will not be drowned in blood, that El Paso, Las Cruces, Albuquerque, all the visitors stepping onto our border, will show solidarity with the good people of Juarez and will continue to visit, to shop, to make a statement that we will aid the good people of Juarez by providing ourselves as international shields to the bullets that today are launched with little concern of that most effective preemptive action. Let's not allow the good Juarenses to be forced to lock themselves away from the streets, the businesses, the parks, the community in which they grew, the community they love.
Turning our backs on Juarez now is like turning a blind eye to an outstretched hand. The emotional support is like a blanket, warm and comforting, but we can do more. We must. Consolation is decent and respectful, but moving to do something to keep tragedy from happening in the first place, to preventing an episode which requires consolation, that is more important, is more proactive in helping Juarez.
Why do I refer to us "turning our backs on Juarez"? Because it is happening, here in El Paso, whose roots are in Juarez, whose economy has been buoyed by Juarez for generations. Bear with me, in this moment, because I write burdened by sadness, feeling, as many of you do, that the goodness in Juarez appears mortally wounded. Bear with my words, with this critique.
The El Paso Visitor's Guide, the official voice of El Paso to the rest of the world, has initiated a policy to limit the mention of Juarez in its pages. They feel it would be "irresponsible" to talk to visitors about Juarez, fearing that people may actually visit the town, across the river.
I can rationalize the City's thinking, and this editorial policy. "Don't do anything to lead people into a city strife with killings." The City, which oversees the Visitor's Guide, created this policy out of a sense of responsibility for the safety of people coming into El Paso. But, really, let's ask the question: "If we try and keep people from going to Juarez, who does this really benefit?"
Let's not forget Rwanda, how the United Nations turned the other way, allowing the death and chaos to churn through the streets unhindered because it was too "unpredictable" to become involved with. That decision to turn away, to wait, to allow the wicked current -- so similar to Juarez today -- was Kofi Annan's biggest regret.
"'The international community is guilty of sins of omission,'" Mr Annan said. "I realized ... that there was more that I could and should have done to sound the alarm and rally support," he has been quoted as saying.
Juarez right now is not unlike Rwanda. There were more deaths in Rwanda -- at the end maybe about 800,000 -- but there was a buildup to that point, when it started with a couple of dozen a weekend, and more and more and more.
When the eyes of the world fall upon you, your behavior changes. The leaders of Juarez, whether corrupt or not, will do more to quell the violence if we do more to bring in that great neutralizing concept of guests in the home. We can't let the deaths continue in the shadows, a light must consume Juarez, compelling them to remedy their problems through the lens of civility that only a global audience can provide.
El Paso Visitor's Guide: Don't omit Juarez from your pages; increase your coverage. Bring in the eyes of the world to the businesses of our sister city. That act alone will help quell the violence, will help the struggling tourism industry that sustains so many families, will help send the message that El Paso will not turn its back on our neighbor in their time of need.
Mr. Mayor: Heed John F. Kennedy's words to Mexico, not so many years ago in his inaugural address: "to our neighbor in the south ... It's time for us to convert our good words to good deeds."
Sound bytes from the mayor that we are "supporting Juarez" are rendered irrelevant if his visitor's guide consciously omits Juarez from its pages, undermining their efforts to return to their normal lives. Such an action by El Paso leadership is not converting good words to good deeds.
Juarez is engulfed in an international crisis, but some of the most influential forces here in El Paso are treating it as a local problem that will go away if we ignore it. Eventually, the cartels will stabilize -- but only for a while. Then the carnage begins again.
We can blame cartels for the deaths, but if we do nothing to bring the world's attention to this situation, if we do nothing to accept that the US drug demand is the second half of this corrupt equation, then we too must share the loathsome burden of responsibility for all the killings to come.
Thank you Ms. Malloy. You helped me many times at the NMSU library in my research of the border. Your work and your words paint a sorrowful picture, and that picture hopefully will move more people to action....